Nuits-Saint-Georges, Fly Me to the Moon!

21 October 2016:

This commune which gave its name to the Côte de Nuits had a little-known claim to fame. In the book “Autour de La Lune” (“Around the Moon”) written by Jules Vernes in 1870, three men took a journey to the Moon and they celebrated their achievement with a bottle of Nuits-Saint-Georges. In a gesture honouring the novelist’s vision, the crew of Apollo 9 mission (James Divitt, David Scott and Russell Schweikart) after visiting the Aeronautic Centre at Le Bourget, were inducted as members of La Confrèrie des Chevaliers du Tastevin by Bernard Barbier, Grand Maître of the Confrèrie as well as Sénateur-Maire of Nuits-Saint-Georges, on 30 May 1969. The following day, at the Mairie of Nuits-Saint-Georges, the party was present at the naming of a barrel of Nuits-Saint-Georges as Cuvée Terre-Lune 1969. Two years later, in May 1971, the crew of Apollo 15 mission: David Scott, Alfred Worden and James Irwin, passed by Clos de Vougeot after their trip to the Aeronautic Centre at Le Bourget, and they were presented with 6 bottles of Nuits-Saint-Georges Cuvée Terre-Lune 1969 for them to take back to Florida. On 25 July 1971, the Mairie of Nuits-Saint-Georges received a telegram from Cape Kennedy, saying that David Scott and James Irwin wished to name one of the lunar craters where they landed on 31 May 1971 as Saint Georges in honour of Jules Verne’s book “De La Terre a La Lune” ("From the Earth to the Moon") written in 1865.

The name “Nui” was first mentioned in 1060 at the Abbaie de Saint Vivant de Vergy. The origin of the name could have come from an ancient word for a flooded valley or the word for a walnut tree, which was very common in the area before 1709. The wines of Nuits gathered fame during the 15th Century under the rule of the Valois Dukes. In 1680, Dr. Fagon prescribed the wines of Nuits to Louis XIV, saying that old wine had marvelous healing effects. All this attested to the excellence of Nuits wines. The current name of the village Nuits-Saint-Georges was formalized in 1892 and thus solved a political debacle around the naming of the railway station in the village (to differentiate from another station also with Nuits as part of its name). During the 19th Century, the climats of Les Didiers, Les Saint Georges and Les Vaucrains were already well know but somehow they were not requested for promotion to Grand Cru status by the Mayor nor the President of the Appellation of Nuits-Saint-Georges in 1936.

Earlier this week, a group of Hong Kong’s trade and media professionals braved the local Black Rainstorm warning and joined the comparative tasting and live broadcast masterclass on the diversity of Nuits-Saint-Georges organised by the Bourgogne Wine Board (BIVB). This edition of the “Rendez-Vous avec les vins de Bourgogne” took us to the heart of Nuits-Saint-Georges vineyards and shared with us the insights of two winemakers, Jérôme Flous, Wine and Vineyard Manager of Domaine Faiveley and Thibault Liger-Belair and their favourite climats in Nuits-Saint-Georges. Winemakers have long respected the multiplicity of this relatively small appellation on the Côte de Nuits, with 41 Premier Cru climats, each with its distinct personality. Nuits-Saint-Georges wines can come from 2 communes, Nuits-Saint-Georges and Prémeaux-Prissey, covering just around 300 hectares, with 160 ha at the village level and 140 ha at the Premier Cru level. Nuits-Saint-George wines are not all red, but the white vineyard area is a mere 3% of the total vineyard area.

Nuits-Saint-Georges could be masculine or feminine, depending on whether you’re at the northern end butting Vosne-Romanée where softer-textured wines with more finesse and complexity tend to be shaped or at the southern Prémeaux end, where the soil contains more clay, giving fuller-bodied and more structured wines. Jérôme Flous said Nuits-Saint-Georges could be an Asian elephant at the northern end, round and tame, whereas the southern end was more like an African elephant, wild and robust. His two favourite climats were Les Porrets Saint-Georges, robust and structured with dark fruit and almost prune like character, and Les Damodes, much more refined, with spicy aromas and juicy fruit. Thibault Liger-Belair chose Les Saint Georges and Les Boudots as his two favourite Nuits-Saint-Georges climats. For him, the former represents the quintessence of Nuits-Saint-Georges, with structure and finesse, whereas latter is all about elegance and softness, being next door to Malconsorts in the Vosne village.

The masterclass included one village lieu-dit Les Argillats and 5 Premier Cru climats, covering Les Damodes and Aux Chaignots at the northern end of the Nuits commune, Les Procès and the celebrated Les Saint-Georges from the southern end of the Nuits commune and one climat from the Prémeaux commune, Aux Perdrix, not to be confused with Aux Champs Perdrix at the northern end of Nuits.

The geology has much to account for the distinct characters of each of the 6 wines, as does winemaker/domaine style. Here in Nuits-Saint-Georges, the closed valleys named Combes in the Côte de Nuits, are much wider and the river Meuzin flows through the valleys, bringing with it a wide alluvial fan with pebbles and silt deposits at the northern end. At the southern end, the alluvia originated from La Combe des Vallerots and the soil at the foothills contains deep marly limestone. In some areas the clay has high iron oxide content, as in Les Saint-Georges.

Nuits-Saint-Georges can be divided into 3 parts. The first part forms border with Vosne-Romanée until the river Meuzin, with 240 metres at the lower end and 350 metres at the top end. Some vineyards are fully facing east, such as Les Damodes and others are fully south-facing, such as Aux Argillats (not the same as Les Argillats tasted in this masterclass). Here we have Les Damodes, Aux Boudots, Aux Chaignots and La Richemone as examples of premier cru climats. The second part begins on the other side of the Meuzin valley and finishes at La Combe des Vallerots. Here we have Les Pruliers, Les Procès, Les Vaucrains and Les Saint-Georges as premier cru examples. The third part is in the Prémeaux commune and it is a much narrower strip with climats as Clos l’Arlot, Clos de la Maréchale, Les Didiers, with hard compact limestone at the top of this strip.

The characteristic finesse and concentration of Les Saint-Georges is due to the topsoil of pebbles deposited from La Combe des Vallerots, helping drainage and acting as heat-traps, and also the high clay content giving structure to the wine. It is located at the border with the Prémeaux commune, where the wines tend to show fuller body and more richness. This is evidenced by the richness and concentration of the Aux Perdrix example by Domaine des Pedrix in the line-up. This is one for the long haul but is not entirely unapproachable now, with richness of ripe fruit coupled with chewy tannin and full-bodied concentration. By comparison, Les Damodes tends to display more elegance and freshness due to its higher altitude and more complexity from the long maturation as a result of its full-eastern exposure. The sample by Frédéric Magnien may be more driven by the winemaker’s style. The Drouhin Les Procès also bears hallmarks of the house style, with its characteristic finesse, understated power, and subtle influence of oak from extended seasoning, despite the high clay content of the climat. Les Argillats combines the freshness from the altitude and the balance and concentration from the vintage of 2014.

2013 was a difficult vintage but the samples tasted showed balance and remarkable freshness. 2014 showed much more concentration and ripeness but it was beautifully balanced as a vintage, without any heaviness at all.

The question of whether Nuits-Saint-Georges would one day have a Grand Cru to justify the quality of its wines still hovered and Jean-Pierre Renard of the Ecole des Vins de Bourgogne gave nothing away!

The wines tasted were:

Nuits-Saint-Georges Les Argillats, 2014, Domaine Philippe Gavignet

Nuits-Saint-Georges 1er Cru Les Damodes, 2013, Domaine Frédéric Magnien

Nuits-Saint-Georges 1er Cru Aux Chaignots, 2014, Faiveley

Nuits-Saint-Georges 1er Cru Les Procès, 2013, Maison Joseph Drouhin

Nuits-Saint-Georges 1er Cru Aux Perdrix, 2013, Domaine des Perdrix

Nuits-Saint-Georges 1er Cru Les Saint-Georges, 2014, Maison Chanzy


Thibault Liger-Belair believes that there are wines for lunch and there are wines for dinner. Nuits-Saint-Georges is definitely a wine for dinner, he says, to be enjoyed slowly, with emotion, with friends. “Never open a bottle alone….and remember: The last glass is always the best.”

Beautiful Old Riojas: 1964 Vina Ardanza Reserva Especial

2 Sep 2016: This dinner took a while to come together and in the end, we lost some people but gained others. It was a remarkable assembly of beautifully aged Riojas, including the legendary 1928 Federico Paternina Ollauri Gran Reserva and the 1964 Viña Ardanza Reserva Especial (released only 3 times in history, 1964, 1973 and 2001). I found the VA in the 1928 a bit overpowering a short while after opening. It was almost madeira like.  We were able to taste two vintages of La Rioja Alta Gran Reserva 904 side by side: 1964 and 1989. They were both divine: 1964 nicely matured, and 1989 still plentiful of vigour. We were also treated to a 1968 Viña Tondonia Gran Reserva Blanco: amber gold in colour, with layers of ginger, nutmeg, Oriental spices, hints of caramel, still showing lots of freshness and a long finish. 

There's something rather romantic about old Riojas.....the silky texture, the liveliness that's still evident in most of the wines, the layers of flavours slowly unfolding on the palate, and the lingering finish. With these, we do not worry ourselves with single vineyards, just the vintage and the skill of the winemaker.  These are wines for a meditative evening, not wines to be consumed in a hurry! 

My top picks from our evening were:

1964 Viña Ardanza Reserva Especial

1964 La Rioja Alta Gran Reserva 904

1989 La Rioja Alta Gran Reserva 904

A couple of white Bourgogne bottles sneaked into our tasting, but they were both much appreciated.

For a traditional evening, the best venue had to be Olé, which never disappoints with its fabulous execution of classic dishes! (http://www.olespanishrestaurant.com.hk/)

1945 Rausan Segla

3 Sep 2016:
1945 Rausan Segla: "Shipped in wood" to the UK for bottling.  Harmonious, seamlessly integrated, mature bouquet of cigar box, violet and leather with caramelized fruit notes, lingering on the finish. Velvety to taste, with no noticeable acetic or oxidative notes. Incredibly well preserved for its age. An ethereal classic claret. Lacking in depth and richness for the vintage to merit a higher score. 19/20

A class above - 1990 Hill of Grace

16 Aug 2016: We finally made it to this long anticipated dinner which was originally going to be a Grange mini vertical dinner. With the passing of time, the theme was swapped for the classic Syrah/Shiraz evening. Impeccable and extremely professional service by the team at Another Place by David Myers @ HIP Cellar, and above all excellent and artistically presented dishes.  There was general consensus that the duck course was the star dish - sadly I did not take a photo - it looked so tempting, that we could hardly wait to tuck into it! 

Marinated kodama watermelon, ama ebi, edamame salad, yuzu kosho

1996 Chardonnay Extra Cuvée de Reserve, Pol Roger 
We started with this champagne. Layers of pear, almonds, brioche, rich and exuberant without heaviness, with creamy mousse and a lively crisp finish. Excellent drop, still very fresh at 20 years! 18/20

2000 Chablis Montée de Tonnerre, Raveneau
Sadly, oxidised aldehyde notes prevented our enjoyment.  This calls for another bottle from the same case to be tasted soon!

The line-up of 4 Syrahs

1978 Hermitage La Chapelle, Jaboulet
Black plum, cardamom, cinnamon, nutmeg, wild herbs, game, black pepper, whiff of VA, vibrant acidity, elegant tannin, very long finish. Not quite the gargantuan 100-pointer that we were expecting. Wine lost its freshness and revealed a dull and coarse palate after about an hour. Worth investigating with another bottle from the same case to see if this wine is at risk of decline. 17/20


1980 Grange, Penfolds
Sweet vanilla, coconut, blackberry, minty chocolate, black pepper, firm structure, velvety tannin, firm acidity. A lush wine with a slightly rustic edge, not quite as suave. Lacked personality. 96% Shiraz. 4% Cabernet Sauvignon. Drink now and over next 8-10 years. 17/20

Interestingly, the 1980 Grange cork did not have any engravings on it.
Just a plain cork.

1990 Grange, Penfolds
Topped up with 2006, recorked in 2011. Blackcurrant, spicy, vibrant acidity, sweet vanilla, coconut, the elegant palate belies a big and powerful structure. This recorked bottle seemed youthful but very ready to please . 95% Shiraz, 5% Cabernet Sauvignon for original vintage. Long way to go. Drink now and over next 10+ years. 17.5/20

Slow-cooked Iberico pork loin, confit fingerling potatoes, yuzu jus

1990 Hill of Grace, Henschke
Gamey, slight hint of black pepper, sweet finish, harmonious, integrated with velvet tannins, minty chocolate, hint VA but enough to detract from its singular beauty and elegance. A stylish wine that has aged magnificently and gracefully. A class above the rest of the flight. Very persistent finish. Drink now and over next 10+ years. 19.5/20 (Very beautifully paired with the duck cooked under sous vide!)

Strawberry shortcake, almond milk, burnt miso ice cream

1882 Ne Oublie, Graham's
Quite different from the Scion. Layers of toasted walnuts, dried orange peel and balsamic nuances. Beautifully integrated. The anticipation from watching the bottle being extracted from the heavy encasement, to being opened, then the pouring and finally the tasting was simply breathtaking. On the palate, there was a freshness that kept the body of the wine lithe and vivacious, whereas from memory, the Scion was more unctuous and opulent. The bouquet lingering on the glass was simply mesmerizing. A very memorable end to a wonderful dinner. 20/20

Our menu - highly recommended!

Domaine Senkin defining the ‘New World’ of Japanese sake

June 2016:

I recently had the opportunity to meet Kazuki Usui, the CEO of Senkin Shuzo (or Domaine Senkin, as Usui-san prefers it being known) at a masterclass and dinner hosted at the China Club by the Drinks Business Hong Kong, in collaboration with Jebsen Fine Wines. As the 11th generation running this ancient brewery that dates to 1806, Usui-san believes that it is his duty to sustain the traditions while innovating with new techniques and styles to ensure the brewery’s continuation in a world challenged by evolving palates in both alcoholic beverages and food. With formal training as a wine sommelier, Usui-san never set out to be a traditional brewer of sake, following the standard recipes for sake brewing. He also understands that to a degree, wine selection at restaurants is driven by grape variety with regional style to pair with the food, whereas sake is more likely to be chosen based on the popularity of the brand. Therefore, his priority was to build the brand for Senkin. Putting a stamp on his individuality, he decided to adopt the Burgundian name of ‘domaine’ for Senkin, and to follow the concept of ‘domaine’, that he would only make sake with ingredients under his full control.

 

Kazuki Usui clutching a bottle of Senkin Tsuru-Kame 19

As demonstrated in the first half of the masterclass where we tasted 5 sake examples from 5 different breweries and prefectures, each with their own qualities of water, defined as hardness of water (amount of calcium carbonate and minerals such as potassium, magnesium and phosphates), water seemed a more dominant factor in influencing the style of sake, much more so than the rice variety. This was brought to light by the example of a sake from Hyogo with hard water called miyamizu and Nagano where the water hardness measured the lowest amongst the 5 examples (almost 1/6 the level of the water in Hyogo). Today, Senkin uses the same water to grow the rice and to brew sake. All the rice varieties in his sake portfolio come from fields in the Tochigi prefecture where the brewery is based.

Further, the brewery has eschewed the special designations requirements (Tokutei Meisho). Instead, Usui-san has developed his own range of ‘Classic’ and ‘Modern’ where in the former, the seimaibuai (rice polishing rate) for both kake mai and koji mai is 50%, giving a rich and rounded style, and in the latter, the seimaibuai for koji mai is 35% and for kake mai, 50%, giving a more elegant style. (Typically in sake production, koji mai or koji rice accounts for about 15-20% of total rice requirement. This is rice inoculated with koji mould that serves to split the starch into sugars for fermentation by yeast into alcohol. Kake mai is the remaining steamed rice.) The more the rice is polished, the closer we get to the shinpaku (starch core), the more refined, balanced and pure the style of sake, with pronounced aromatic profile, smoother texture and crisp finish. Within the special designation sake or premium sake which only accounts for 30% of total sake production in Japan, a sake can only qualify as Honjozo with a minimum of 70% seimaibuai, and 60% for Ginjo and 50% for Daiginjo, although 35% seems the norm for high quality Junmai Daiginjo. Rice polishing is laborious and requires time and care. Usui-san has just produced a barrel of sake with just 7% seimaibuai. It took 15 days to achieve this level of polishing rate, which reduced the brown rice grain to just a mere white speck of extreme fragility. This nerve-wrecking process would necessitate meticulous instructions in soaking and steaming, all supervised with extreme care. It was produced in batches of 20 kg and the soaking took exactly 1 minute 30 seconds, no more no less, in water at 6°C. This was followed by steaming for 45 minutes. (Compared with a 50% seimaibuai batch of 200kg, the steaming would normally take 90 minutes.) For 2.5 tonnes (2,500 kg) of rice, this method only produced 400 bottles, instead of the standard 5,000 bottles. Senkin produced one barrel only of this 7% seimaibuai sake, made with Kame-no-O, the signature rice of Tochigi prefecture, that has earthy complexities, dry style and a high degree of acidity. Half of this barrel was exclusively bottled for Jebsen Fine Wines for their own label Kikusaki. It is no surprise that Kikusaki Nana (‘Nana’ is the Japanese word for ‘seven’) comes with a high retail price tag of HK$ 3,200 a bottle. Usui-san recommended service temperature of 8°C.  

 

When asked Usui-san why he went for 7%, he replied that another brewery had produced 8% and he wanted to push the boundary further. While he can continue to experiment with the seimaibuai (ie going lower), he will turn his attention to refinement of other production techniques. We tasted his Nature-un. It was made using the kimoto technique, with natural lactic acid bacteria and natural yeast, and a seimaibuai over 90%, quite the reverse of the 7%. The intensity of umami flavours was astonishing, with such savoury complexities of dried Chinese mushroom, truffle and yeast. From the expressions on the face of a few participants, it might be more of an acquired taste. I kept some behind for the dinner and thought it went extremely well with the fried rice with roasted duck, mushroom, shrimp and conpoy in abalone sauce, scented with black truffle, for that explosion of umami flavours!   According to Usui-san, this can be enjoyed at either 18-20°C or at 45-50°C.

In future, Usui-san will also be experimenting with different types of barrels. He used a Bourbon barrel in the production of the 7% seimaibuai sake.

Contrary to the practice of adding water to dilute sake from the genshu state of 17-20% abv, there is no such practice at Senkin. So technically, they are all genshu.  In addition, there is no fining nor filtration at Senkin.

The hallmark of Senkin sakes is the balance of acidity and sugar, sometimes more than barely noticeable sweetness. The acidity was particularly marked for Senkin Issei, a 35% seimaibuai, based on Yamadanishiki rice.  It would go particularly well with fish and seafood, according to Usui-san. The noticeable sweetness could work very well with lightly spicy food, and I would like to retry the Modern Senkin Yamadanishiki with Thai cuisine for example. In fact, everyone thought this sake went very well with the ginger in the dish of braised pork spareribs with citrus fruit paste and young ginger, but the sweetness of the citrus fruit paste was a bit too overpowering for the sake.

Perhaps the widely acknowledged all-rounder and most wine-like was the Tsuru-Kame 19, with 19% seimaibuai and Kame-no-O as the rice variety. Usui-san recommended serving it at 8-10°C.  I likened it to a Chablis, with energy, tension and balanced freshness. 

Senkin is definitely charting new waters for a traditional beverage of over 1,500 years. The mystique of sake is that unlike wine (a grape variety, married with climate and soil, that would give an expected style), with sake, it is not so obvious, with so many variations that could make a difference, from water quality, soaking time, soaking temperature, rice polishing rates for koji mai and kake mai, kimoto or sokujo, natural yeast or cultured yeast, pasteurization or not, filtration or not, to ageing methods, and so much more! This matrix of variations is not meant to be confusing.  Rather, it opens up new avenues for a traditional beverage to find new amateurs who can enjoy it with different types of cuisine and on different occasions. There should be a sake for everyone and every moment!

The sakes tasted in the masterclass and dinner were:

Masterclass

Flight 1 

1) Manotsuru Junmai Daiginjo (真野鶴純米大吟醸実来): Koshitanrei, 35% RPR, Niigata Prefecture

2) Hakuko Junmai Daiginjo 50 Sarasoju (白鴻純米大吟醸沙羅双樹50): Yamadanishki, 50% RPR, Hiroshima Prefecture

3) Fukuju Junmai Mikagego (福寿純米御影郷): Yamadanishki, 70% RPR, Hyogo Prefecture

4) Takizawa Tokujo Honjozo (瀧澤特撰): Hitogokochi, 59% RPR, Nagano Prefecture

5) Michizakura Junmai Aiyama (三千櫻純米愛山): Aiyama, 60% RPR, Gifu Prefecture

 

Masterclass Flight 1

Flight 2

6) Senkin Tsuru-Kame 19 (仙禽鶴亀19): Kame-no-O, 19% RPR, Tochigi Prefecture

7) Senkin Issei (仙禽一聲): Yamadanishiki, 35% RPR, Tochigi Prefecture

8) Modern Senkin Omachi (モダン仙禽雄町): Omachi, 50% RPR, Tochigi Prefecture

9) Classic Senkin Kame-no-O (クラッシク仙禽亀の尾): Kame-no-O, 50% RPR, Tochigi Prefecture

10) Senkin Nature Un (仙禽ナチュラルアン): Kame-no-O, >90% RPR, Tochigi Prefecture

 

Masterclass Flight 2

Dinner

1) Senkin Issei (仙禽一聲): Yamadanishiki, 35% RPR, Tochigi Prefecture

2) Kikusaki Nana(菊咲 7): Kame-no-O, 7% RPR, Tochigi Prefecture

3) Modern Senkin Yamadanishiki (モダン仙禽山田錦): Yamadanishiki, 50% RPR, Tochigi Prefecture

4) Senkin Tsuru-Kame 19 (仙禽鶴亀19): Kame-no-O, 19% RPR, Tochigi Prefecture

5) Classic Senkin Kame-no-O (クラッシク仙禽亀の尾): Kame-no-O, 50% RPR, Tochigi Prefecture

6) Modern Senkin Omachi (モダン仙禽雄町): Omachi, 50% RPR, Tochigi Prefecture

7) Modern Senkin MUKU (モダン仙禽無垢): Hitogokochi, 50% RPR, Tochigi Prefecture

8) Senkin Ume-jiri (仙禽梅尻)

 

Dinner Selection

Ganpai!

9th Edition of Musique et Vin au Clos Vougeot

June 2016: We felt very privileged to be invited to join a couple of events at the 9th edition of Musique et Vin au Clos Vougeot, a music and wine festival that brings together amateurs of Bourgogne wine and music to raise funds to support young artists. David Chan, Concert Master at the Metropolitan Opera Orchestra, has been artistic director of this festival since 2008. Through the participation of David and his friends, a Franco-American inter-cultural exchange has been fostered in the spirit of music and wine. The 2016 festival also saw the brilliant performance by violinist Renaud Capuçon, cellist Gautier Capuçon, baritone Ildar Abdrazakov, and soprano Hyesang Park, who along with violinist Vladimir Percevic, are the two 2016 winners. Conductor Charles Dutoit delighted the audience with his brilliant and animated leadership of the orchestra and singers at the final concert at Clos Vougeot, which consisted of arias from the Barber of Seville and Don Giovanni, as well as a beautiful Concerto No. 1, by Camille Saint-Saëns and a symphony by Georges Bizet. The entire concert was able to take place open air, under a canopy which rather nervously supported the strong winds.

Two days prior to the final concert, we also attended the concert at Château de Meursault and were regaled by such magnificent pieces of Johann Sebastian Bach’s Concerto Brandebourgeois No. 1, No. 4 and the most captivating No. 3, with the flawless performance by a number of musicians, including violinists David Chan, Abraham Appleman, Catherine Ro and Katherine Fong, and flautists Magali Mosnier and Jose-Daniel Castellon, amongst others. The concert had actually decamped to the church nearby in anticipation of the storm that threatened to arrive early evening. This was followed by La Paulée Musicale at Château de Meursault, whereby everyone took a bottle (or more!) to share with other guests. The atmosphere at La Paulée is always very convivial, with plenty of vinous generosity, banter and animation of Le Bon Bourguignon. We tried so many wines that we failed to record them all. However I recalled tasting an excellent 1995 Charles Heidsieck Blanc des Millénaires, an elegant 2008 Château Lafleur and a brilliant 2001 Raveneau Chablis Les Clos, a 1989 Clos Vougeot Gros Frère et Soeur, a 1990 DRC Grands Echézeaux, 1988 Clos de Tart (magnum) and the 2006 DRC Romanée-Saint-Vivant which we rather tasted hastily, I felt. We took a magnum of 1988 Domaine des Chézeaux Griotte-Chambertin and that was rather delicious too!

Anthony Hanson and Clement working hard at auctioning the lots

The finale evening at Château du Clos Vougeot finished with a charity auction, with the generous support of various domaines. A well-fed and suitably ‘wined’ audience eagerly awaited every lot being declared by auctioneer Anthony Hanson who rattled through the 31 lots (2 impromptu lots were added during the course of the evening) with electrifying speed and was most persuasive with his succinct and effective descriptions of each lot in both French and English. The result was an enormous success, raising EUR 250,000 compared to EUR 178,000 last year. Some really special lots featured such as 2 magnums of Clos de Vougeot Cuvée des Moines de Cîteaux 1997 (being 2 of 150 magnums produced from a single barrel to celebrate the 900th anniversary of the foundation of the Abbaye de Cîteaux, using grapes from every climat of the Grand Cru), a jeroboam of Clos de Vougeot Hommage à Jean Morin, Château de La Tour, 2013 (an ultra-rare cuvée launched in 2010 and only declared in exceptional vintages, made with only the first cluster from the first shoot of the very old vines dated from 1910, ) and a bas relief sculptured wood representation of Saint Vincent, with original polychrome paint (this was won by our friends at Fine Wine Experience!). The final lot of a magnum of DRC Romanée-Conti 2005 went for an extraordinary sum of EUR 100,000, making it the most expensive lot. The second most expensive lot went for EUR 12,000 and it included a magnum of Corton Clos Rognet, Méo-Camuzet 2006, a magnum of Clos Vougeot, Domaine du Clos Frantin 2012 and a bottle of DRC La Tâche 2009.

Hyesang Park delighting the audience with her Korean rendition

Over the years, the festival has received much support from both France and overseas, including a number of overseas sponsors. No doubt the enthusiasm for the auction at the Clos Vougeot dinner was prompted by the quality of the wines that were served at dinner! Ildar Abdrazako and Hyesang Park respectively captivated the diners with renditions in their own languages, Russian and Korean.

Here were the wines served at dinner: 

Champagne Blanc de Blancs, Delamotte

Meursault Charmes-Dessus 2013, Château de Meursault

Puligny-Montrachet Les Pucelles 2004, Domaine Leflaive

Chambolle-Musigny Les Beaux Bruns 2012, Joseph Faiveley

Clos des Lambrays 2011, Domaine des Lambrays

Echézeaux 2009, Domaine de la Romanée-Conti

Château d’Yquem 2005

Liqueurs Gabriel Boudier


The weather behaved extremely well during the week-long festival. Apart from the extreme heat and torrential storm on 24 June, we had clear sky and mild temperatures that made it a most pleasant week. We look forward to joining the festival again next year!

Chaptalisation is like adding that pinch of salt....

24th June 2016, at 32°C outside, the cool cellar of Domaine Mugneret-Gibourg was a welcome change. The inflorescence has now formed but the first budbreak has not happened yet in Bourgogne. Continued sunshine and warmth would be perfect, but every vigneron was dreading the hailstorm that was predicted to arrive later in the evening, that would threaten to decimate the crop, especially after the ravages of late April frost. Domaine Mugneret-Gibourg had already lost 99% of their Chambolle-Musigny Les Feusselottes to frost. It was difficult to imagine how hail could materialize when all we could see was ferocious heat and bright blue sky.


We were received by Marie-Andrée at Domaine Mugneret-Gibourg. The domaine was created in 1933 upon the marriage of Jeanne Gibourg and André Mugneret. Georges Mugneret was their only son, a trained ophthalmologist, who kept his medical career going while being involved in the family profession. He met his wife Jacqueline while serving in Algeria. Marie-Andrée and Marie-Christine, her elder sister of 9 years, took over the domaine when their father passed away prematurely in 1988, after having finished the vinification for that vintage. Marie-Andrée was still at school then and she formally joined her sister a few years later, in 1992. The two sisters share responsibilities in the winery, for example bottling is Marie-Christine’s sole responsibility and Marie-Andrée fiercely defends her chaptalisation responsibility. According to Marie-Andrée, chaptalisation is like adding a pinch of salt when baking. It adds a certain dimension to the taste but it is inconspicuous on the palate. For her, chaptalisation is vital for the balance of wine, adding between 0.2 – 0.5% abv, religiously every year. An exception is 2009 when there was so much phenolic and sugar ripeness that no further adjustment was necessary. The culinary comparison does not stop here: Marie-Andrée assures us that adding sugar to fermenting must creates a most enticing aroma.


In the vineyards, they prefer la lutte raisonné, instead of definitively going down the route of organic, to be assured of a safe and healthy crop. For example, in 2013, they had to spray herbicide against flavescence dorée, and in 2016, they had to spray against mildew. However, in 2015, with such fine and warm weather, no chemical products needed to be used.


We tasted a range of 2014 of their wines. Flowering was early in 2014, happening at end May (unlike end June this year), summer began hot but a big hailstorm wreaked havoc on the last Saturday of June, affecting mostly Pommard, Volnay, Savigny. August remained cold (that the heating had to be switched on). Fine weather returned beginning of September and they were able to harvest around 20th September.


The domaine’s maximum production is around 120 barrels, but on average it’s around 100 barrels, with some vintage variations, such as 68 barrels in 2012, 102 barrels in 2014 and 90 barrels in 2015.

 

We tasted Vosne-Romanée village (from the climats of La Croix Blanche, Au Bas Combe, La Colombière and Les Chalandins), Nuits-Saint-Georges Les Chaignots, Chambolle-Musigny Les Feusselottes, Echezeaux (50% from Les Rouges du Bas climat which brought minerality, and 50% from Les Quartiers de Nuits which contributed power, like in Clos Vougeot), Ruchottes-Chambertin (Ruchottes du Bas) and finally Clos Vougeot. The Ruchottes-Chambertin was a very elegant balance between finesse and power, with just perfect concentration. The domaine bought this parcel in 1953 and replanted in 1954. The Clos Vougeot seemed more austere with a firmer structure, having come from vines over 60 years of age. The family had owned another parcel of Clos Vougeot previously and Georges was given some large formats from the 1929 vintage. This parcel was subsequently sold. The 1929 Clos Vougeot was such a great wine that Georges decided to purchase a parcel of Clos Vougeot located in the Montiotes Hautes climat, while still in medical school then.


The last jeroboam from the glorious 1929 vintage was drunk last year on the occasion of Jacqueline’s 80th birthday.

 

Marie-Andree explaining to us that it's the family tradition to taste the Clos Vougeot after Ruchottes-Chambertin

We then tasted a few 2015’s from barrel. We tasted Echezeaux, Ruchottes-Chambertin and Clos Vougeot. The last two were particularly impressive, with such freshness, concentration and character than the 2014 vintage. They seemed such complete wines at the moment, that they would be rather sensational with some bottle age. In 2015, the natural alcohol was between 12.5 abv and 13.2% abv.

The domaine uses 4 coopers for their different characters.


The wines all showed distinct expression of terroir, with beautiful balance, silky texture, refined tannins and subtle power for the Grand Cru wines. This is a domaine that delivers consistently and produces some really beautiful and expressive and harmonious wines. 2015 clearly showed a big step up on 2014! Do not miss the Ruchottes and Clos Vougeot when released en primeur.


NB. The hailstorm predicted for 24 June did not materialize to the relief of all vignerons. Instead, we had a furious rainstorm that lasted all night.

Bourgogne’s regional appellation wines finding their place in a crowded global market

18 June 2016: Last Wednesday (15 June), on behalf of BIVB, I hosted a blind tasting of white Bourgogne wines for a group of over 20 trade professionals, including sommeliers, importers, educators and press, at HIP Cellar in Hong Kong (www.hipcellar.com). As per the format of previous trainings, it was broadcast live by BIVB to a number of cities at the same time.  The theme of the session was "Fresh Bourgogne White Wines for Hot Moments".  The reason for the blind tasting and the lack of mention of regional appellation wines in the invitation was to allow local trade to appreciate the diversity and regional nuances of regional appellations of Bourgogne, without being prejudiced.

 

HIP Cellar and Another Place by David Myers

Of the 100 appellations in Bourgogne, 23 appellations are at the regional level, 44 at the village level and 33 at the Grand Cru level. Looking at the average data between 2009 and 2013 (a somewhat representative period which included the sizeable crop in 2009 and the much reduced crops of 2010, 2012 and 2013), the regional level accounts for just over half (around 51%) of total Bourgogne production of about 200 million bottles. The Grand Cru level contributes scarcely over 1% of the production. This leaves the balance of the production volume to village level wines which represent around 38% of the production, and their 640 Premier Cru climats, the remaining 10% or so.

Regional level appellations are generally regarded as the entry point to the world of Bourgogne wines, and can typically be spotted by having the word ‘Bourgogne’ in the appellation. Immediately springing to mind would be Bourgogne Pinot Noir, Bourgogne Chardonnay, Bourgogne Aligoté and Crémant de Bourgogne. However, they can also be associated with a delimited region, eg Bourgogne Côtes d’Auxerre, Bourgogne Hautes Côtes de Beaune or a village, eg Bourgogne Vézelay or Bourgogne Chitry, or even a climat, eg Bourgogne Côte Saint Jacques.  There are 4 such regional appellations associated with a climat, the other three are Montrecul, Le Chapitre and La Chapelle Nôtre-Dame.   The exceptions without the word 'Bourgogne' in the appellation name are: ‘Mâcon’, ‘Mâcon-Villages’ and ‘Mâcon + name of one of 27* villages’.

Speaking to the audience behind the screen during a live broadcast directly from Beaune, Jean-Pierre Renard, Official Educator of the Ecole des Vins de Bourgogne, said in his introduction, these wines could be described as: convivial, easy-to-drink when young, friendly, fresh and lively, and a festive ring to the Crémants. However, even at the regional level, there is diversity in character and that the style (and quality) is certainly not homogeneous. They are wines of terroir especially the Bourgogne Plus and Mâcon wines.  The yields in general for the Bourgogne Plus wines are generally lower than for Bourgogne Chardonnay or Bourgogne Pinot Noir.  Production volumes and sizes of delimited areas vary amongst the different regional appellations. Mâcon and its variations are produced from around 3,868 ha. Area of production for Bourgogne Hautes Côtes de Nuits is 698 ha for its red, rosé and white wines. Bourgogne Vézelay currently covers about 330 ha, with production of 312,000 bottles.  Crémant de Bourgogne, with its production volume of over 17 million bottles in 2015, technically can be produced anywhere in Bourgogne as long as it is produced according to the requirements in terms of grape varieties, production method and ageing.

One thing that I have often found baffling is that the area of production of Chablis is also large – it is about 3,367 ha, without counting the Premier Cru and the Grand Cru sites. The official yield limit for Chablis is 60 hl/ha. For the Mâcon white, it is 70 hl/ha, whereas Mâcon + village name, it is 66 hl/ha. [Out of interest, the actual average yield for Bourgogne Hautes Côtes de Nuits was about 50 hl/ha between 2007 -2011.] One would expect that the actual yield is lower and does not differ so much between Chablis and Mâcon+village, for example, especially in the hands of quality-conscious growers. Therefore, I find it interesting that Chablis is a village appellation and Mâcon and its villages are mere regional appellations. It is true that Chablis has garnered a widely recognized brand - the Chablis growers have invested much time and resources to achieve this and that they have marketed their uniqueness derived from a very unique soil of Kimmeridgian marl. Parts of the Grand Auxerrois region also seem to share this epoch of soil, as we were reminded during the live broadcast training. This explained the flinty character and saline finish of the Bourgogne Côtes d’Auxerre, although it was somewhat masked by 10% new oak in an ambitious effort on the part of the producer.  However, Bourgogne Vézelay, in the southern part of the Grand Auxerrois region, though on clay-limestone soil, has much more clay than Chablis, giving rise to more fruity wines.

Another really interesting point is ex-cellar pricing for regional and some of the village appellation wines. Ex-cellar pricing for regional wine is about EUR 5-10 per bottle, as we were told during the training. I guess Petit Chablis and Chablis are pretty much in the same range, with some Chablis Premier Cru leaving the cellars at around EUR 10 a bottle for a sizeable order.

 

We learnt from Mathieu Woilliez, Owner of Domaine de La Crox Montjoie, the exciting new development for Bourgogne Vezelay, that of the 330 ha, 250 ha will be upgraded to a village appellation, Vezelay AOC, in 2017, with the balance remaining as Bourgogne Blanc.

For this tasting, BIVB selected the following 6 wines. Under blind tasting conditions, the participants had to guess which regional appellation each wine came from. The wines from Le Mâconnais showed more generosity, balanced with freshness, in the difficult 2014 vintage, marred by cool weather early season, humid summer and issues of millerandage. The two wines from the Grand Auxerrois region showed a clear expression of terroir between the two: one crisp and fruity with a saline finish from the higher clay content in the soil and the other more ambitious with its new oak treatment and a flinty character, with its association with the Kimmeridgian marl. The Hautes Côtes de Nuits, from vines that overlooked Nuits Saint Georges, showed structure and complexity that distinguished it from the others. The Crémant showed elegance, balance and layered complexity.

Of our group of 20, 2 people got 4 out of 5 correct! And some got 2 or 3 correct, with quite a few getting none correct! [It had to be 5 as the Crémant was rather too obvious!]

 

Mâcon-Milly-Lamartine, Château des Bois, 2014, Château de la Greffière

Mâcon-Igé, Château London, 2014, Domaine Pierre-Yves & Olivier Fichet

Bourgogne Vézelay, L’Elégante, 2014, Domaine de La Croix Mont-Joie

Bourgogne Côtes d’Auxerre, Cuvée Louis Bersan, 2014, Domaine JL & JC Bersan

Bourgogne Hautes Côtes de Nuits, Les Dames Huguette, 2014, Domaine Guy & Yvan Dufouleur

Crémant de Bourgogne, "J'aime être gourmande" par Colette, Caves Bailly Lapierre

We took a vote of which wine the participants liked best amongst the still wines and the Bourgogne Hautes Côtes de Nuits received the most votes at this tasting, although the two Mâcon wines had their supporters too. Everyone thought the Crémant was of very high quality.

Regional appellations are not a static group - in fact they represent a dynamic image and they work hard to attract more consumers.  They constantly look for ways to improve quality of their wines and to generate consumer interest in their innovations.  For example, the Union des Producteurs-Elaborateurs de Crémant de Bourgogne launched a new premium classification system earlier this year: Eminent (min. 24 months ageing on lees) and Grand Eminent (min. 36 months ageing on lees, only using the cuvée (or juice from first pressing), and based on Pinot Noir and/or Chardonnay only, plus other requirements on dosage, time between disgorgement and release and minimum alcohol content). This move is to explain to consumers the higher quality wines of Crémant de Bourgogne from the label and to differentiate from standard Crémants which only have minimum ageing requirement of 9 months on lees.

It was hoped that this tasting would introduce some of the lesser known regional appellations to the trade so that they could explore further afield than just Bourgogne Rouge and Bourgogne Blanc for their by-the-glass programme. As Mathieu Woilliez of Domaine de La Croix Montjoie said, these Bourgogne regional appellations are suited for people who already know Bourgogne well and who are keen to explore. Feedback from the audience afterwards seems to confirm that an excitement about these appellations was certainly incited, the quality and terroir expression acknowledged and interest generated.


There seems a two-fold challenge: availability and an apparent lack of means to be marketed and distributed in a competitive marketplace, especially against the better known Chablis or simply Bourgogne Rouge/Blanc. This begs the question of education – the more the trade professionals know about these interesting regional appellations, the more willing they will be to seek them out, and the more effective they will be in convincing the consumers to try something different. Lafon and Leflaive have both included Mâcon wines in their portfolios, and I believe the ‘star’ power has helped cast the spotlight on some lesser known regional appellations that deserved attention. But that has only worked for the Mâcon, to a limited extent. More needs to be done. Borrowing the Prosecco example, a short vintage in 2015 sparked speculation that other categories of sparkling wines could capitalize on the supply-demand gap and make a dash for increasing market share. Perhaps a vintage with reduced Chablis production could give these regional appellations a chance to position in the international market, or where the difference of a Euro per bottle ex-cellar could make a big difference to the wholesaler/importer? However, we must not forget that each regional appellation has its own identity and unique style, let alone style of the winemaker. There cannot be one solution for the regional appellations!

This was a great demonstration of the richness and diversity of Bourgogne as a region, that even at the regional level, there was so much to offer, and it left us all with a strong impression of the quality of regional appellations. It seems to me that each producer will need to find his/her own market-positioning solution, with the support of BIVB, international media and wine experts. It will be a great day when I see a Bourgogne Côtes d’Auxerre on a restaurant wine list in Hong Kong! 

* NB: Of which, 26 can produce white (including variations on this theme, ie some can only produce white, some can produced white, red and rosé), but with one of the 27 only producing red and rosé.

Magnificent 1971 Conterno Barolo

11 June 2016: Invited to friends' home for dinner.  It was the original intention to have an Italian evening and our very hospitable hosts prepared a sumptuous menu of dishes including homemade taglioni with cuttlefish ink.

The evening started with a delicious 1998 Dom Perignon which was followed with a bit of diversion from Bourgogne and Portugal, before we homed in on the original Italian theme. The 1996 Vosne-Romanée Les Petits Monts, Joseph Drouhin was elegant and silky, showing its age but gracefully.

We were all rather impressed by the 2013 Meruge, Lavradores de Feitoria.  It was a blend of Tinta Roriz, Touriga Franca and Touriga Nacional, from a vintage marked by unusually low temperatures in April/May, followed by a hot dry summer and a wet September. This was a remarkable effort showing elegant balance, with an uplifting vibrancy, richness of fruit, spicy complexity, and a smooth texture. The alcohol, though high, did not throw the wine out of balance, supported by the ripeness of fruit.  The oak would need a bit more time to integrate completely but it was not too offensively overt (the wine was matured in new French oak for 12 months).  It was a well-crafted wine that could please the palate now or for further cellaring for 6 - 8+ years for further evolution.  Established in 1999, Lavradores de Feitoria is a co-operative consisting of 18 growers, with vineyard area of around 800ha in the Douro, from a range of altitudes 200 - 500 metres.  For Meruge, the grapes are sourced from two north-facing cool vineyards, thus explaining the freshness (for 2013, it recorded 5.3 g/l acidity).

Although it was brought by us, we had to admit that it was the star of the evening for us: 1971 Conterno Barolo, our last bottle. The last bottle was quite out of condition, so it was with a bit of anxiety when our host served it from the decanter. (We blind tasted all the wines.)  Underneath a slight whiff of volatile acidity, there was a glorious mature Barolo bouquet of dried roses, earth, hint of tar and leather.  The palate was silky and the finish long and harmonious.  A beautifully aged Barolo.  Richard felt that there was cellaring potential but I probably wouldn't keep this any longer.

The estate famed for premium Barolos with extreme longevity, was founded by Giovanni Conterno in 1908.  Giovanni believed in making the best Barolo and therefore it would only be made in great vintages.  When his son Giacomo returned from WW I, he joined his father in running the estate. Giacomo's 2 sons, Giovanni and Aldo, worked together until 1969 when Aldo broke off to set up Poderi Aldo Conterno.  Until the 1970s, the estate had no vineyards - it made wine from bought grapes.  As more and more farmers began bottling their own wine, the estate decided to purchase its own land.  In 1974, the estate purchased the densely planted 17-acre Cascina Francia vineyard in Serralunga d'Alba, one of Piemonte's great monopole vineyard (SW exposure, 400 metres high). Winemaking is traditional here from Giacomo's days: natural yeast, temperature-controlled fermentation, long maceration and ageing in Slavonian botti and bottles for 4 years before release.  So this bottle would have been made by grapes sourced by the estate.


The other wine that I particularly liked was the 1994 Gaja Sitorey (mostly Barbera with some Dolcetto).  I had thought it was a mature Barbaresco, still retaining plenty of freshness, but with the tannins softened out.  The new oak was well-integrated, and the bouquet was hint of spice, dried cherry, tar, and some leather. The acidity was still prominent and made great pairing with the roasted chicken and mozarella parcel. It was a very stylish wine, quite different from the humble Barbera and Dolcetto!  1994 was a disastrous vintage in Piemonte.  Angelo Gaja declassified 50% of his crop.

An American's Road to Burgundy - 8 years on

7 June 2016: As part of the Winemaker Dinner Series at Crown Wine Cellars, a small group of HK’s collectors, trade and media professionals had the opportunity to meet Ray Walker, owner and winemaker of Maison Ilan and author of “The Road to Burgundy” that documented the extraordinary story of an American falling in love with Burgundy wine, convincing his then pregnant wife that they should abandon life in the US, his job and salary at Merrill Lynch to move to Burgundy to make wine, when he only had one harvest experience under his belt and nothing else. It was a captivating story – a page-turner that kept you fascinated, and made you want to meet Ray and try his wines!

Almost 3 years after reading this book, I finally had the opportunity to meet Ray Walker. 2016 would be his 8th vintage in Burgundy, having launched his first wines from the 2009 vintage. Since writing the book, Ray has now complemented his hands-on experience with some technical training. He believes in minimal intervention, likening his wine to ‘sashimi’, not even ‘sushi’ with garnishes of rice, mirin, sesame and seaweed – just plain good quality fish, served ‘naked’ without any embellishments. In his minimalist cellar, he only has a destemmer, some hoses, fermentation vats (stainless steel tanks) and seasoned barrels. You will not find new barrels at Maison Ilan. Ray typically uses 2 or 3 year oak barrels to age his wines. Older barrels are used too for extended ageing: an example was his 2011 Chambertin, which he aged in barrel for 27 months. Having experimented with stems in 2009, he now only practices whole berry fermentation but not whole clusters.

No stems, no oak, no additions (except sulphur) and gentle extraction form the framework of his modus operandi. High temperature tends to over-extract. So he keeps the temperature to a moderate level, while only punching down 3 times in total during fermentation/maceration, rather than the traditional practice of 2 – 3 times, for 10 – 14 days. He adds nothing to his wine, except sulphur - all yeast and lactic acid bacteria are ambient. Instead of the usual topping-up of barrels during ageing, he drops marbles into the barrels to replace any empty head space. The minimalist approach involves just one racking, before bottling.

So how were the wines? We tasted 2 bottles from his first vintage 2009: Morey-Saint-Denis Les Chaffots and Chambertin. One could say this was the first Chambertin made by an American! Also tasted were samples from 2011, 2012 and 2013 vintage.

 

Ray Walker and the wines he served at Crown Wine Cellars

Ray had them served in this order:

2013 Volnay 1er Cru Les Robardelles

2013 Morey-Saint-Denis 1er Cru Les Monts Luisants

2013 Morey-Saint-Denis 1er Cru Les Chaffots

2013 Mazoyères-Chambertin

2013 Charmes-Chambertin ‘Aux Charmes Hauts’ (to differentiate from Charmes Bas)

2011 Chambolle-Musigny Les Feusselottes (from a parcel of 85-year-old massale selection vines)

2011 Morey-Saint-Denis Les Chaffots

2011 Chambertin

2009 Chambertin

2009 Morey-Saint-Denis Les Chaffots

2012 Chambertin (2 bottles were shown, with noticeable bottle variation)

The group was evenly split between those who liked Mazoyères and others who were partial to Charmes. Ray said people could get very emotional about his sauvage and sinewy Mazoyères and commented that its followers were usually also lovers of truffle – the umami factor? The Charmes showed precision, purity, finesse, depth of character, with a velvety texture.

 

To be the minimalist he is, Ray needs access to high quality fruit. The quantity of fruit he bought since he started has grown from 10.5 barrels of the 2009 vintage to 30 barrels of the 2015 vintage. He went back to 18 barrels with the small-crop 2012 vintage. The prices keenly reflect the demand for high quality fruit in Burgundy – Ray is now paying double what he paid when he started buying in 2009.

According to winesearcher.com, his 2011 Charmes Chambertin Aux Charmes Hauts is about GBP 100 a bottle and his Chambertin 2011 about GBP 85 a bottle.

Ray admitted to earlier challenges with logistics and distribution, but he believes there is now a much more organised and efficient system to allow him to focus on other projects, including a TV production sequel to his book. Fans of his first book would need to wait quite a bit longer for the second volume.

From 1945 La Tache to 1999 Mugnier Chambolle Les Amoureuses

Level shown here after pouring just the amount in the glass

4 June 2016: We did not expect this to be promising, given the below shoulder level, but there was just this glimmer of hope, especially with such a precious bottle.  Coffee, hazelnut, caramel, burnt sugar, leather, with a high level of aldehydes wafting from the glass. Sercial-like on nose. Volatile acidity dominates the aftertaste but there is still a shade of the bygone glorious and elegant persona. A grande dame that sadly is in the decline ramp.

So we switched to the 1999 Chambolle-Musigny Les Amoureuses, Mugnier. Ruby hue. The purity of fruit overlies the developing tertiary character of sous-bois, mushroom and sweet spice of cardamom and vanilla. Sinewy, vibrant with an initial austerity/tightness characteristic of the vintage. I feel I can taste the brilliance of the winemaking and the attention to the vines during the growing season. There is no hurry to drink this beautifully and sensuously textured and layered nectar. Just coming into drinking window, and more evolution over next 10-15 years. 19/20

We started the evening with a really tasty 2013 Saint Aubin Derrière Chez Edouard, Hubert Lamy. I adore this name for its idiosyncratic image. It is vibrant, with plenty of tension to complement the complexity, followed by a nice long finish! A well-made wine for now or the next 5-6 years. The difference between 2012 and 2013 is very poignant. Such a welcome return to a classic style with an approachability that is so appealing. 17/20

1989 La Tache

1 May 2016:

1989 La Tâche: Richard chose this for the long weekend. Initially, it was rather ungenerous, with just tertiary character of leather, mushroom and sous-bois, overlaid with a hint of volatility. The structure concurred it was a wine of pedigree and finesse, but the palate seemed a little tired, lacking in concentration and depth and finishing dry. We were relieved that after about 2 hours, it started displaying signs of life and vibrancy. The fruit notes returned, together with dried rose and cardamom character, and the mid palate also filled out nicely, leading to an elegant finish. It seemed a wine in its prime, at the plateau of its drinking and would continue to drink well for 8 - 10+ years. 17/20 (Richard gave it 92.)

Varietal Confusion!

28 April 2016:

I had been waiting to try them side by side....and finally found the opportunity to enjoy them with a friend and a big supporter of all things Swiss! They were both by Jean-René Germanier and from the 2009 vintage. Previously I had only tried Cayas Syrah from this estate, so I tried to research a bit as to what to expect. Both red, and both wines had been aged in barriques for 12 months. I looked up "Wine Grapes" and it says that Humagne Rouge is actually Cornalin. I was left a bit confused for a little while.  But to my rescue, I was really pleased to have this explained to me by one of the co-authors, Dr. José Vouillamoz.

I quote Dr. Vouillamoz's explanation here:

"Humagne by Jean-René Germanier is the Valais name for Cornalin from Aosta Valais, described in "Wine Grapes" under Cornalin.

Cornalin by Jean-René Germanier is different from Cornalin from Aosta Valais (hence from Humagne Rouge) and it is described under the name Rouge du Pays in "Wine Grapes". The unfortunate name change occurred in 1972 when it was decided in Valais to rename Rouge du Pays to Cornalin, by "borrowing" the name of an ancient variety from the neighbouring Aosta Valley. Hence the confusion."

Confusion indeed! But they were both really delicious, and very distinct in style!

2009 Humagne, Jean-René Germanier: Ruby core. Red berries, cherry, mineral, crushed stone with gamey and spicy nuances. Some hints of black pepper. Silky tannin. Soft acidity. Enjoy now and over next 4 - 5 years.


2009 Cornalin, Jean-René Germanier: Ruby core. Plum, dark cherry, blackberry, vanilla, smoke, gamey, herbs, sweet spice. Fine but robust structure, firm velvety tannin balanced with vibrant acidity. Enjoy now or over next 8-10 years.

Thank you Damien (Fleury) for introducing them to me: www.theswisswinestore.com

Under-rated Ageing Potential of South African Iconic Reds

One of the more interesting wine tastings during the South African Wine Festival 2016 was a tasting of 5 back vintages from the library stock of 4 iconic wineries, hosted by Hong Kong’s wine merchant Northeast Wines. 

The first vintage (1995) of Hartenberg Wine Estate Gravel Hill Shiraz, under current winemaker Carl Schultz, had been produced exclusively for the 1997 Cape Winemakers Guild auction and this marked the first of 14 vintages sold at the CWG auction.  The quality of the low-yielding (about 3 tons/ha) single vineyard Shiraz is largely due to its unique soil composition. The thin topsoil (30-50 cm gravel) overlies the subsoil of metres deep of clay performing the function of water regulation.  The winter rain filtering through the gravel is trapped in the fissures in the subsoil, forming the water reserve to feed the growing season.  As the summer heat subsides and rain arrives, the clay swells to prune the roots, limiting vigour of the vines during the ripening period.  The wine spends about 7 – 8 years at the winery before release.  The vertical tasting showcased the 5 vintages from 2005 to 2009, its most recent release.  Retail price of the 2008 vintage is HK$ 575 (or US$ 74).  The family-owned Hartenberg Wine Estate was established in 1692.  Its vineyards on the slopes of Bottelary Hills bordering Stellenbosch are renowned for high quality Shiraz. (see: www.hartenbergestate.com)

Kanonkop Estate has long been known as the First Growth of South African wines. With vineyards on the lower slopes of the Simonsberg Mountain in Stellenbosch, Kanonkop is a fourth generation family estate.  The estate was originally purchased by JW Sauer, a cabinet member in the parliament of the Union of South Africa.  Here 5 vintages of the Cabernet Sauvignon-dominant Bordeaux blend Paul Sauer, including the award-winning 2009 vintage, was showcased at this special tasting. Retail price for the 2011 vintage is HK$ 321 (or US$ 41).  (See: www.kanonkop.co.za)

Hannes Myburg, 8^th generation owner of Meerlust Estate, presided over the pouring of Meerlust Rubicon wines, spanning the vintages 1998, 2001, 2005, 2009 ad 2012.  Meerlust was established in 1756.   The first vintage of Meerlust Rubicon was 1980. Hallmarks of Rubicon are intensity, harmony, vibrancy and complexity. The complexity is further enhanced with 1% addition of Petit Verdot from the 2009 vintage.  The wines are released after 4 years in the winery and the magnums are released after 10 years.  Not every vintage would produce a Rubicon.  The last 40 years saw gaps in 1985, 1990, 2002 and 2011, according to Myburg. The 2012 vintage retails at HK$ 294 (or US$ 38). (See: www.meerlust.co.za)

Traditional basket presses are used to craft this elegant Syrah, with grapes from 3 parcels in Stellenbosch.  Low yields, carefully selected fruit and gentle extraction give rise to this special cru from one of Stellenbosch’s oldest winery.  Originally known as ‘Bellinchamp’ (pretty fields), the Bellingham story began in 1693 when Hollander Gerrit Janz van Vuuren and his French Huguenot wife planted the first 1000 vines on the estate. When Bernard and Fredagh Podlashuk (“Pod”) purchased the derelict farm in 1943 and set about to restore it, thus began the modern renaissance of the Bellingham Estate in Franschhoek.  “Pod” was a pioneer and Bellingham was the first to release a single varietal Shiraz in 1956.   The 5 vintages of Bellingham Bernard Series Basket Press Syrah showcased were 2007, 2009, 2010, 2011 and 2012.  (See: www.bellinghamwines.com)

South African native and long-time HK resident, Greg De’eb, who also heads fine wine storage facility Crown Wine Cellars, believes that beautifully aged South African Bordeaux blends, Syrah and Pinotage are where Napa Cabernets were 20 years ago.  They were under-appreciated (and under-priced at the time) but possessed the ability to age gracefully and effortlessly, that only took decades to reveal.  De’eb was referring to the mature Napa reds from 60s, 70s and 80s that he was able to buy at sensible prices before the prices sky-rocketed.  De’eb particularly treasures his collection of South African reds, “The Cabs and Bordeaux blends are particular cause for celebration because of their distinctly old world/French character which means with age comes the very best of mature claret.” At a recent dinner at a private home in Hong Kong, De’eb’s host produced a magnum of 1986 Kanonkop Cabernet.  Not one of the connoisseurs present spotted its South African origin, most thought it could only be a first or second growth Bordeaux.

Based on the online retail prices for the wines showcased, one might do well by following the wisdom in De’eb’s advice.

Sarah Wong, wine columnist for local newspaper, SCMP, believes that the ageing potential of the wines is under-rated.  Wong says, “All the wines shown seem so youthful still, that they seem to have years, if not decades, ahead.”

While the 1998 Rubicon has now reached the plateau of its drinking window, Myburg says, “The ageing profile of South African wines is like the country’s famous Table Mountain!” He expects the 1998 Rubicon will stay in this plateau phase for a very long time.

A Rhone Evening: 1989 vs 1990 Cote Rotie La Turque and 2006 Henri Bonneau Cuvee Marie Beurrier!

15 April 2016: Once in a while, we need a wine theme that's not Bordeaux or Bourgogne (wish it were a joke!). This time the Rhone theme made it to the short list! (A friend did sneak in a couple of non-Rhone bottles.)

2010 Condrieu, Tardieu-Laurent. Golden in colour. Oily texture with a lightness. Honey, candied apricot, honeysuckle, frangipani. Soft acidity. This went rather well with the Thai pizza starter.

2008 Châteauneuf du Pape Blanc, Tardieu-Laurent. Also golden in colour. More lively acidity. Grapefruit, nutty, lanolin, fruit peel.

1989 Côte Rôtie La Turque, GuigalSpice, pepper, liquorice, black berry jam, with nuances of leather, smoke. Very long finish. Quite brûlee in character. Layers of complexity with richness and depth. This wine kept evolving throughout the evening. Extremely long finish. More flamboyant in style.

1990 Côte Rôtie La Turque, GuigalLuscious, bright fruit character, youthful, with lively acidity. Smooth velvety texture. More classic in style. Shorter finish than the 1989.  

(La Turque is approximately 93% Syrah and 7% Viognier.  42 months in new oak.)

2006 Châteauneuf du Pape, Cuvée Marie Beurrier, Henri Bonneau

Plum, white pepper, spicy, fruit cake notes. Velvety texture. Soft acidity. Finished long and a very fine wine! Went very well with five spiced braised beef. 

This cuvee started in 1988. It took the name of Bonneau's aunt. The blend is made from 90% Grenache and 10% Mourvèdre, with small portions of Syrah, Counoise, Vaccarèse occasionally. No destemming normally. Vinification in traditional, concrete tanks. Ageing in a combination of old foudres and barriques.

2007 Châteauneuf du Pape Cuvée Reservée, Domaine du PegauPlum, red fruit, slightly jammy note. It was delicious and correctly made but did  not have the same depth or level of complexity as the previous wine.

2008 Mitis, Amigne de Vétroz, Reserve, Jean-René Germanier (18 months in new oak.) Mango, dried apricot, ripe pear and marmalade with notes of macadamia. Long finish. The wine could do with a bit more acidity. But it's voluptuous and a beautifully balanced drop.